Who Murdered Abby and Andrew Borden? Myster Readers' Theatre Unit
Included in the Who Murdered Abby and Andrew Borden Mystery Readers’ Theatre Unit:
14 page script
10 characters
1-3 narrators
1 Collecting Evidence: Suspects and Victims organizer page
Student Success Criteria
Student Friendly Goals
Teacher’s Reader’s Theatre Checklist
Writing Rubric
Who Murdered Abby and Andrew Borden? synopsis:
In Fall River, Massachusetts, August 4th, 1892, Abby and Andrew Borden are found brutally murdered by their daughter Lizzie and their maidservant Bridget. A doctor is called and neighbour Mrs. Churchill calls the police. Lizzie claims that she left the front door open when she went into the garden… or was it the barn… and while there, a sneaky axe-wielding maniac entered the house and murdered her wealthy parents. Her parents were also found to have poison in their bodies. Officers MacTavish and Billows investigate the crime while journalist Elizabeth Jordan of the New York World News observes and reports her findings. Lizzie is the main suspect but will she be found guilty of the murder of her step-mother and her father? Was the culprit really someone from the neighbourhood with an axe to grind or a scorned fellow who felt slighted at a business deal with the wealthy and miserly Andrew Borden? This looks like a case for your classroom of detectives to solve. Will your class find Lizzie Borden guilty or not guilty of the murders of Abby and Andrew Borden?
Mr. Marvel’s Musings:
I have received requests for more classroom mysteries (along with the usual cries for more horror haha :) ) I decided to add a historical tale of mystery and horror.
I did not add details of the murders. There are 3 murders in this mystery. A cat, Abby Borden and Andrew Borden. At first, I added the details for historical fact, but my colleagues and I removed them and just state that they were found murdered with no details as to how they met their demise. These stories are read by a variety of classrooms with varying levels of sensibilities. If you choose to tell your class the details and show the disturbing pictures of the scene of the crimes, then you may do so at your discretion because you know your students better than anyone. That is another reason I did not create a historical slideshow for this mystery.
I originally titled this mystery “the axe of Lizzie Borden” but it was too direct. I found this alternate title to be more mystery.
Along with the suspect and victims organizer, I also encouraged students to use mind maps and branching organizers to sort their evidence from the story.
The names used in this story are factual, except for the names of the two officers.
I read this twice with one grade 6 class because they wanted to hear it again so they could write down evidence from the story.




















